The Weekender #7: Gifts
This weeks question comes from David:
Is there anything about the whole BDSM 'scene' that bothers you?
Well. I've spent a long time trying to think my way through this one, as there is something that bothers me a lot about the BDSM scene. However, I think it's something that'll annoy quite a lot of people out there... so much so that I deferred the question by a week to try to come up with an answer.
Here it is. The thing that bothers me about the BDSM scene is large numbers of submissives who proclaim that their submission is a gift to their dominant. Many of these people, in my mind, are only offering their submission with several strings attached... Yes, in a very real sense a gift is given "without compensation", but those who proclaim their submission as a gift, also proclaim it as something they can chose easily to give and take away.
I have always felt submissive. Not only in the sexual sense, but in every day living. When there were arguments, I tried my hardest to resolve them, often feeling like I was the one in the wrong when I was trying to state my point of view, and often submitting to the other person to "make them happy". I have always wanted to please my parents, often taking my mother's odd mannerisms to keep her from becoming displeased with me. Even now, there are many things I do to try to keep the peace and please my significant other - I cook, I clean, I do the washing when he can't, I remind him of things, I plan his diet so he doesn't feel ill, I try to offer solutions to his problems. To me, all of this is part of my submission to him. All of this is part of who I am.
To say that all of that is something that I chose to give him, and something that - should he mistreat me - I'll be able to take away again doesn't sound true. All of those actions, even down to cleaning (which I don't enjoy), are actions that I do to please him. I don't do them because I feel that I am giving to him, I do them because I want to be cherished, I want him to be pleased with me... and maybe I'd get a reward. Therefore, these actions are not a gift, they are done with a goal in mind - even if that goal is as simple as "the house will be tidier, and HE will be pleased with me". I think that if we ever do break up, I'll find it extremely hard to take my "gift of submission" back again, it's something I'll always be giving him - if not in house-hold chores then in respect when I meet him - and it'll be something that'll be very hard to break.
Further more, I find that those who proclaim their submission as a gift are those who expect even more in return. To quote one example, "Oh, I could never give myself to someone who doesn't love, respect and care about me. Someone who doesn't want to take care of me forever, solve my problems, give me roses every week, is always romantic, never demanding and who wants to marry me too. To this man, I'll give my submission," Read through that statement again, admittedly taken out of context (this isn't the author's view), and you'll see that actually there are many strings attached to the "slave's" submission - even the rather vanilla strings of "is always romantic" and "buys me roses every week".
One thing that I find I want to conclude is this: if submission is a gift, then so is friendship in general. So is marriage, and so is dominance. In each of those scenarios, the one who is giving is also getting something in return, be it a mutual friendship, teamwork or someone willing to be dominated. After-all, who is a submissive if she doesn't have any one to submit to?
I feel that there is much more that I want to say, but can't find the right way to say them. There is one part of the "gift theory" that I appreciate - it makes the consentual part of the relationship clear. This is something that shouldn't be forgotten. At the end of the day, a dominant has no right to force his submissive to stay in the D/s relationship. To sum up, I'll once again refer back to a blog named "Submusings" written by KrynInterrupted: “The submission is the dedication and commitment that makes the power exchange possible. That is the gift because it’s given freely and whole-heartedly.”






